Raw Milk Cream Cheese (Thick & Spreadable)

Smooth, tangy, and rich — homemade cream cheese is a homestead favorite. With just raw cream, a starter, and a little time, you can whip up a spreadable cheese perfect for bagels, cheesecakes, or dips. Unlike store-bought, this version is fresh, simple, and free of additives.

Affiliate note: This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thanks for supporting Grandma’s Homestead!

---

Quick Facts

• Skill: Intermediate
• Yield: ~2 cups cream cheese from 1 quart cream
• Active time: 20 minutes • Inactive time: 12–18 hours culturing + draining
• Shelf life: 1–2 weeks refrigerated

---

Ingredients

• 1 quart raw cream (or whole raw milk for lighter cheese)
• 2 tablespoons mesophilic starter culture or 2 tablespoons buttermilk
• 2 drops liquid rennet (optional, for firmer texture)
• ½ teaspoon cheese salt (optional)

---

Equipment

• Stainless steel pot
• Thermometer
• Cheesecloth or butter muslin
• Strainer/colander
• Bowl
• Food processor or hand mixer (optional, for whipping smooth)

---

Step-by-Step Instructions

1. Warm the cream
   Heat cream gently to 75–80°F in a clean pot.
2. Add starter & rennet
   Stir in mesophilic starter (or buttermilk). If desired, add rennet for a thicker curd.
3. Culture
   Cover and let sit undisturbed at room temperature for 12–18 hours, until thickened like yogurt.
4. Drain
   Pour curd into a cheesecloth-lined strainer set over a bowl. Tie corners and let drain 6–12 hours, until desired thickness.
5. Salt & whip
   Transfer curds to a bowl, mix in salt, and whip with a spoon or food processor until smooth.

---

Flavor & Use Ideas

• Stir in herbs for garden-fresh cream cheese.
• Add honey + cinnamon for a sweet spread.
• Use in cheesecake, frosting, or dips.

---

Troubleshooting (Quick Fixes)

• Too runny: Needs longer draining time or a touch of rennet next batch.
• Too tangy: Cultured too long; shorten ferment time.
• Grainy texture: Didn’t whip smooth after draining. Blend briefly for creaminess.

---

FAQ

Can I freeze cream cheese?
Yes, though texture becomes crumbly. Works fine for baking after thawing.

Can I use store milk instead of raw?
Yes, but avoid ultra-pasteurized cream, which won’t culture properly.

Is rennet required?
No — it just helps thicken. Buttermilk or starter alone will still work.

---

🧊 Raw Milk Handling & Safety Guides

Proper handling makes all the difference in quality, flavor, and safety:

• How to Store Raw Milk for Freshness
• How to Tell If Raw Milk Has Spoiled

🧀 What to Make With Fresh Milk

Once you’ve got milk in the fridge, here’s what you can do with it:

• Homemade Feta Recipe

🚜 Want to see everything I use on the farm — not just what’s mentioned here?

I made a cozy little storefront with ALL the tools I reach for day-to-day in the barn, kitchen, parlor, and pantry.

👉 Head to the Farm Favorites Shop 🐄

It’s how I keep this homestead runnin’ and the cows content.

👉 Join the Herd below and come along for real-life homestead lessons, raw milk info, and stories from our farm.